Sileph and Enna: some are upset by this relationship, but it occurs to me how important stories are, how a distanced reader can see and understand things that a character can't. And in turn, that helps us take a step back from ourselves and see and understand ourselves better. How many people have been in a relationship like Enna's with Sileph but couldn't see it for what it was?
"You lying son of a goat." Feel free to use this at need. You have my permission.
Someone close to me had a hard time with this book, and it occurred to me that she had never made any big mistakes. Maybe it's uncomfortable for those who have lived a quiet kind of life to try to empathize with a character like Enna.
A note to myself in an earlier draft: "What are Sileph's motivations? Does he really love her?" I came to my own conclusion in later drafts but since the text doesn't specifically say I'll let you decide for yourself.
Rebecca asks, "Would you rather have this series adapted into movies or a TV show ...or neither if you had the choice?" Ooh, wouldn't a Game of Thrones style miniseries be wonderful? If done well. But I highly doubt any of the Bayern books will ever be made into a movie. The Goose Girl was optioned years ago. And I remember (about 7 years ago?) someone shopping it around as a potential vehicle for a young actress. Obviously nothing happened. It's very rare that any book is optioned for a potential movie, and of those that are, maybe 10% actually are made into one. The only power a writer has in the matter is to wait, and if someone asks, to say yes or no. That's it.
Viola says, "Haha, they definitely have stood up to many rereads--with me, at the least. They're my go-to books for when I've got nothing else to read. I've lost count of how many times I've read each one. Each time, they feel like old friends and new adventures all at once. I'll never grow out of them." Thank you! Someone who read a draft of the last book in the Princess Academy trilogy (not out yet - next spring) said that reading it felt like coming home. I feel that way too when I write these characters.
If the Goose Girl was a movie, who would you want to play Ani and Enna?
Posted by: Anna | July 22, 2014 at 04:11 PM
"Have you never lied, Enna? [Sileph asked.] "I have lied. I have lied and tricked and done everything I could think of to get you into this camp and keep you here."
As much as I would love to hate Sileph for all he does to Enna during this chapter - and he does a LOT that deserves derision - this part always brings me pause. Do I hate him just because he's being mean to her by lying and manipulating her? I think so ... but I don't know if he really cares for her either. :/ Tiedan is the one we hear say what the plan is, and Sileph doesn't really interrupt him, so is the plan REALLY what's in his heart?
There are times that I read this chapter and believe that he cared for Enna - likely not "Love" in the grand capitol letter way, like Finn so obviously does - but he was probably attracted to her. Most likely to the Fire Power she bore.
Posted by: Audrey | July 22, 2014 at 10:28 PM
This chapter made me happy because I was still rooting for Finn and didn't trust Sileph. I wanted him to be a horrible person lol
Posted by: Heather | July 23, 2014 at 05:36 AM
Are any of the characters in Enna Burning LGBTQ+?
Posted by: Lizza | July 23, 2014 at 09:30 AM